Case 15 · External claim
Case 15 — a +90.2% annualised claim, recomputed
Source: Collective2 marketing email, "Trading Strategy of the Week: Adaptive Investments", 2026-11-06 15:07Z. Claim under test: Hypothetical Annual Return (Compounded) +90.2%. Verdict: the arithmetic is consistent with the published monthly table. The number is hypothetical, not an audited real-money return, and it is carried by a small number of months.
1. What the email says
- Manager runs the strategy with real money in an Interactive Brokers account; $3,521,990 of real capital follows it; 217 others follow.
- The first line of the email is "All results are hypothetical."
- Monthly table (%, sign as printed):
| Year | months |
|---|---|
| 2024 | -3.8, +8.3, -0.5, -7.9, +5.3, +3.9, +4.5 |
| 2025 | +8.5, +0.1, +0.6, +50.7, +7.6, +4.5, +3.3, +10.9, -, +6.2, +12.4, +10.7 |
| 2026 | +14.1, +23.4, -20.9, +20.3, -6.1, -8.9, -3.9, +2.8, +9.3, +18.5, +2.2, +50.1 |
2. What I recomputed
Compounding the monthly cells:
- 2024 (7 months): +9.16%
- 2025 (11 months, September missing): +180.27% — the email prints YTD +180.4%
- 2026 (11 months): +49.9% — the email prints YTD +50.1%
- Full span: ~+350%, which annualises to ~90.3% on the email's own basis ⇒ the +90.2% is arithmetically consistent.
3. What the number hides
- Concentration. The three largest months are +50.7%, +23.4%, +20.3% (plus one +180.4% YTD figure). Remove the three largest monthly cells and the annualised figure falls to ~34.8%.
- Drawdown. On monthly closes the worst peak-to-trough is -21.8%; 2026 has a -20.9% month followed by -6.1%, -8.9%, -3.9%.
- Basis. The displayed track record is a model account. C2's own disclaimer says "there is no single real-life trading account that looks exactly like the track record shown here." The "Trades-Own-Strategy" badge certifies the manager trades it with his own money; it does not turn the displayed curve into an audited statement.
- Costs. C2 states profits are reinvested and fees are estimated, not taken from a broker statement.
4. Scope and limits
- Recomputed only from the monthly percentages printed in the email; no trade data, no daily equity, no broker statement.
- I did not verify the manager's real account, the $3.52M figure, or the "Top 1%" rank.
- This note is about the claim, not about the strategy's future returns.
5. How to use it
If a seller quotes a compounded annual figure, ask for the monthly cells and recompute three things: the compounding, the figure without the top three months, and the worst monthly peak-to-trough. Those three take minutes and separate "arithmetically consistent" from "durable".