Case 5 · Costs
Case 5 — Cost omission: a take-profit smaller than one round trip
Symptom. A high-turnover strategy backtested at 50x reported +30% over ~83 days with 749 round trips and a clean equity curve. No fee, funding or slippage line appeared anywhere in the engine.
Root cause. The engine credited PnL on every close but never debited a
cost. bal += margin * pnl_pct / 100 was the only balance mutation in the
loop — no taker fee, no per-bar funding, no spread. The reported profit was the
gross move, not the net one.
Why it is fatal here, not merely optimistic. A 50x move needs only a
+0.08% price change to reach a take-profit of +4 (percent of margin):
0.08% * 50 = 4. But one round trip at the venue's taker fee of 4.5 bps per side is
0.09% of notional. The target is smaller than the toll:
| Quantity (as % of notional) | Value |
|---|---|
| Take-profit target (4% of margin at 50x) | 0.08% |
| Round-trip taker fee (4.5 bps x 2) | 0.09% |
So a winning trade, once its own costs are charged, is a loser. No amount of signal quality fixes an edge below the toll.
What the checker found. Reconstructing per-trade notional and holding bars
and running auditkit.checks.fees.check_trades:
| Rule | Count |
|---|---|
ONE_SIDED_FEE (no fee recorded at all) |
749 |
FUNDING_ONCE (funding not charged per bar) |
162 |
| total | 911 |
What the costs would have been (in the audited book; venue taker fee 4.5 bps/side, funding 1 bp/bar funding, 2 bps/fill slippage; notional 400 per side):
| Item | Amount |
|---|---|
| Reported gross profit | +24.2 |
| Fees | 269.6 |
| Funding | 40.1 |
| Slippage | 119.8 |
| Total cost | 429.6 |
Cost is ~5.4x the starting capital and ~17.8x the reported profit. Even on a maker-only assumption (2 bps/side) the fees alone (119.8) exceed the capital.
Bottom line. The headline number was an artifact of charging nothing. In a high-turnover strategy, cost is the strategy: if the average edge per trade is below the round-trip toll, the backtest's profit cannot exist live. Write the cost model first, then the signal.
Caveats. The fee is the venue's real taker rate (4.5 bps/side); funding and slippage are tool-default placeholders — calibrate both to your venue. Notional is taken as margin x leverage. Absolute numbers scale with all three — the structural point (target < toll) does not.
How to reproduce. python3 cases/repro_cost_omission.py charges the venue rate
against a same-shape book of zero-cost round trips and prints the toll-vs.
target arithmetic. Per-item totals move with the holding-bar mix (the repro's
own book differs slightly from the audited one); the structural point does not.
Anonymized: no venue, symbol or account data.